Worker and employer
The ART Review Process: How a Refused 186 Is Lodged, Heard and Decided
The ART review process to appeal a 186 visa or nomination refusal starts with an application lodged, and the $3,727 fee that applies from 1 July 2026 paid, within 28 days of being notified, because the Administrative Review Tribunal has no power to extend that time; you then provide documents and attend a hearing before the Tribunal decides.
Checked against Home Affairs and the Migration Regulations · updated
Want an immigration lawyer to check your 186 before it is lodged? Ask about your 186

- Time to lodge the appeal and pay the fee
- 28 days after notification14 in immigration detention · no extension · Act s 347(3), (5) · as at 24 September 2026
- Tribunal application fee
- $3,727fees paid from 1 July 2026 · 50% hardship reduction
- Department's statement to the Tribunal
- Within 10 working days of noticeAct s 352(2)
- Time to ask for reinstatement after a missed hearing
- 28 daysAct s 368C(2)
- Written decision sent to you
- Within 14 days of the decisionAct s 368A(2)
The Department sends the Tribunal its statement within 10 working days, you add your evidence through the online account, and a Tribunal member decides, usually after a hearing that many finish in under 3 hours. Those steps come from section 352(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the Tribunal’s own pages, read on 24 September 2026.
The step card below sets out the order and the time limits.
| Stage | What happens | Time limit | Where the rule is |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Lodge | Apply online to the Tribunal | 28 days after notification; 14 in immigration detention | Act s 347(3) |
| 2. Pay | Pay $3,727, or at least 50% with a hardship request | By the same deadline | Tribunal’s fees page |
| 3. Documents | The Department gives its statement and file; you add evidence | Statement within 10 working days of notice | Act s 352(2) |
| 4. Hearing | You, and any witnesses, give evidence to a Tribunal member | Many finish in under 3 hours | Tribunal’s hearing page |
| 5. Decision | Given at the hearing or later, then in writing | Written statement within 14 days of the decision | Act s 368A(2) |
Can you appeal if your Australian visa is refused?
Yes, a refused visa can be appealed to the Administrative Review Tribunal when the Migration Act makes the decision reviewable, and the refusal letter says whether it is, who can apply and by when. Section 66(2)(d) of the Act requires a refusal notice to state that the decision can be reviewed, the time for applying, who can apply and where. The Tribunal’s immigration and citizenship page says the same: the decision letter “will tell you” whether the Tribunal can review it.
For a migration refusal the deadline is 28 days after you are notified, or 14 days in immigration detention (section 347(3) of the Act). A visa refused on character grounds under section 501 follows its own expedited pathway, with 9 days to apply if you were in Australia when refused. Who may apply for a refused 186 visa or nomination, and from where, is set out on the 186 review page linked at the end of this page.
How do you lodge an appeal at the ART?
You lodge an appeal at the ART in five steps, and the first three must be finished within 28 days of being notified.
- Read the refusal letter. Find the criterion the refusal turned on, the reasons, and the review details, which section 66(2) of the Act requires for a visa and regulation 5.19(15) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) requires for a nomination.
- Lodge online. The Tribunal calls online lodging “the easiest and safest way”, with a valid email address; the online account lets you add documents at any time and see what you sent. If you cannot lodge online, use Form M1 (if you are not in detention), email reviews@art.gov.au, write to the Tribunal or visit a Tribunal office.
- Give the details and pay. Attach the decision letter or, without it, give your name, contact details, the date and description of the decision and one identifier, such as your date or country of birth, citizenship or passport. Where the decision relates to a visa application and you are not the visa applicant, for example an employer appealing a nomination, also give the visa applicant’s details. Pay the fee, as the next section explains.
- The Department’s file arrives. The Tribunal confirms receipt and tells the Department (section 352(1)). The Department gives the Tribunal a statement of its findings, the evidence and its reasons within 10 working days, and any other relevant documents it holds (section 352(2), (4)). You may ask the Department for access to that written material (section 362A), and the Tribunal must put to you any information it would rely on to affirm the refusal and invite your comment (section 359A). To appoint a representative or an authorised recipient after lodging, use Form MR5.
- Attend the hearing and receive the decision, as the sections below set out.
Paying the ART fee before the deadline
For a migration appeal the ART fee of $3,727 must be paid before the deadline for applying, not after lodging, in three steps. The Tribunal’s fees page says “you must pay the fee before your deadline for applying for a review”.
- Choose full fee or 50%. Pay $3,727, or at least 50% if you will ask for a hardship reduction, by the deadline.
- Pay by an accepted method. Visa or Mastercard online or by phone, or EFTPOS, cheque or money order at a Tribunal registry.
- Keep the confirmation. The Tribunal sends a letter confirming the application; keep it with your refusal letter.
Fee reduction for financial hardship
An appellant who would suffer financial hardship can ask for a 50% fee reduction, but must pay at least the 50% by the deadline and then send the request for fee reduction form with evidence before the review is finalised. The fees page lists evidence such as payslips or Centrelink statements, rent or mortgage costs, bills and the last month’s account statements. If the request is refused, the full fee is payable or the review does not go ahead, and a refused request cannot be reviewed.
How long does an ART appeal take?
An ART appeal of a migration decision took 1 year and 5 months for half of cases and 2 years and 9 months for 95%, for reviews finalised between 1 March and 31 August 2026. Those are the figures on the Tribunal’s processing times page, read on 24 September 2026.
| Migration reviews finalised 1 March–31 August 2026 | Half of cases | 95% of cases |
|---|---|---|
| All migration reviews | 1 year 5 months | 2 years 9 months |
| Nomination and sponsor approval reviews | 1 year 6 months | 2 years 4 months |
| Bridging visa reviews | 11 days | 1 year 1 month |
The Tribunal says the figures are “a guide only”, and it publishes no figure for 186 reviews alone. It can expedite a review where documentary evidence shows the refused criterion is now met, or where exceptional circumstances make the review urgent.
A person appealing a refusal to the Tribunal can enrol in Medicare while the appeal runs, with proof of the appeal and a visa that allows work; people seeking judicial review or ministerial intervention cannot, according to Services Australia. The documents for Medicare enrolment are on the Medicare page.
What happens at a 186 review hearing?
At a 186 review hearing a Tribunal member hears the evidence on the criterion the refusal turned on, and the worker, the employer or both can give evidence under oath or affirmation. The Tribunal’s hearing page says many hearings finish in under 3 hours.
- How it runs. The member explains what will happen, you or your lawyer speak for you, and witnesses give evidence. No one may examine or cross-examine a person giving evidence (section 366D of the Act).
- Interpreters. The Tribunal arranges and pays for a qualified interpreter; a relative or friend cannot interpret.
- Record. The hearing is audio-recorded, and in migration cases you can ask for a free copy of the recording at the end.
- Public or private. Hearings are usually public, and a private hearing is ordered only for good reason (note to section 367B).
- The decision. The member may give the decision at the end of the hearing (section 368(3)) or later. The Tribunal says conferences and conciliation cannot be used in immigration cases, for legal reasons.
If you do not attend, the Tribunal may dismiss the appeal. You can ask for reinstatement within 28 days after notice of the dismissal, with no extension beyond that for migration reviews; otherwise the dismissal is confirmed and the refusal is taken to be affirmed (section 368C(2), (5) and (6)).
Can you reapply instead of appealing?
You can reapply instead of appealing only where the law lets you make a new application, and a person in Australia without a substantive visa who was refused a visa since last entering is limited by section 48 of the Migration Act to a few prescribed visas. Section 48(1) applies “whether or not the application has been finally determined”, so it bites even while an appeal is on foot.
For the 186, Class EN is not one of the prescribed visas in regulation 2.12, so a person caught by section 48 cannot lodge a new 186 in Australia. A new application made from outside Australia is not subject to section 48. Public interest criterion 4020 can still bar a new grant for 3 years after a refusal for bogus documents or false information. On the employer’s side, a new nomination can be lodged at any time, with a new fee of $540 (nil for TRT and Labour Agreement positions in regional Australia) and a new levy of $3,000 or $5,000, as at 24 September 2026. Withdrawing an appeal to reapply ends the review and leaves the refusal unchanged.
After the ART decides: your 186
After the ART decides, what happens to your 186 depends on whether it set the refusal aside or affirmed it.
- Set aside, varied or remitted. The Department reconsiders the 186, bound by any order that a criterion is taken to be met (section 349(2) of the Act; regulation 4.15(1) and (1A)). The Tribunal refunds 50% of the fee paid, and the written statement of the decision reaches you within 14 days of the decision (section 368A(2)).
- Affirmed. A Bridging visa A usually ends 35 days after the Tribunal’s decision (cl 010.511(1)(b)(iii)). An application for judicial review must be made within 35 days of the date of the decision, which the court may extend (section 477(1)–(3)). The Minister may substitute a more favourable decision, but acts personally and has no duty to consider a request (section 351(3) and (7)).
Who may apply, the deadline and the fee for a 186 are on the 186 visa review page, and what was refused, and why are 186 visa applications refused, is on the refusal page.
What changed on this page
| Date | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 24 September 2026 | Page published: the ART review steps for a refused 186, with the time limits in Migration Act ss 347, 352, 368A, 368C and 477 (Compilation No. 171). | Migration Act 1958 (Cth), Compilation No. 171 |
The hearing is where a 186 review is decided
The 28 days to lodge and pay cannot be extended, the Tribunal decides on the evidence and the replies it receives, and a missed hearing can end the review. An immigration lawyer can lodge in time, request the Department's file, prepare the evidence on the refused criterion and attend with you, which makes a decision in your favour more likely.
Ask about your 186