Worker and employer
186 Visa or Nomination Refused: What Happens Next
A refused or withdrawn 186 nomination means the linked visa cannot be granted, and only the employer has the right to ask the Administrative Review Tribunal to review a refused nomination, within 28 days of being notified.
Checked against Home Affairs and the Migration Regulations · updated
Refused or withdrawn? A migration lawyer can read the letter before day 28. Ask about your 186

- Deadline to apply for Tribunal review
- 28 days after you are notified14 days in immigration detention · cannot be extended · Act s 347(3), (5) · as at 24 September 2026
- Tribunal application fee
- $3,727fees paid from 1 July 2026 · 50% reduction for financial hardship
- Who can seek review of a refused nomination
- The employer (nominator) onlyreg 4.02(4)(e), (5)(d)
- Who can seek review of a refused visa
- The visa applicant, from inside AustraliaAct s 347A(1)(a), (2)
- Visa application charge refunded on refusal
- Not usuallyDepartment's refunds page · as at 24 September 2026
A refused 186 visa is the worker’s to take to the Tribunal, from inside Australia, by the same 28-day deadline and for the same $3,727 fee, and the Department does not usually refund the visa application charge. Its refunds page says “The second instalment is not payable if your visa application is refused or withdrawn before the second instalment is paid”. Because every 186 rests on two applications, the employer’s nomination and the worker’s visa, both applications have to succeed in every stream, and the home page shows which 186 stream fits you.
Was it the nomination or the visa that was refused?
A 186 refusal is a refusal of either the employer’s nomination or the worker’s visa, and the refusal letter says which, who can seek review and by when. For a nomination, regulation 5.19(15) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) requires a notice of refusal with reasons and a statement that the decision can be reviewed. For a visa, section 66(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) requires the notice to name the criterion not met, give written reasons, and state whether the decision can be reviewed, the time limit, who can apply and where.
The refusal decision table sets out each case (as at 24 September 2026; fee for fees paid from 1 July 2026; general information, not advice on a particular letter).
| What was refused or withdrawn | Who can seek review | Deadline | Tribunal fee | Effect on the other application |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nomination refused | Employer only (reg 4.02(4)(e), (5)(d); Act s 347A(1)(d)) | 28 days after notification | $3,727 | The visa cannot be granted without an approved nomination (cl 186.223, 186.233, 186.242) |
| Visa refused, lodged in Australia | Visa applicant, in Australia when applying (s 347A(1)(a), (2)) | 28 days; 14 in immigration detention | $3,727 | The nomination is a separate application and is not refused with the visa |
| Visa refused, lodged outside Australia | Only if in Australia when refused and when applying (s 338(7A), 347A(3)) | 28 days | $3,727 | As above |
| Both refused | Employer for the nomination, worker for the visa | 28 days each | $3,727 each (a reading: see below) | The visa needs an approved nomination |
| Nomination withdrawn by the employer | None: a withdrawal is not a reviewable decision (s 338; reg 4.02(4)) | None | None | The visa cannot be granted; the Department says a new nomination cannot be linked to the existing application |
| Visa withdrawn by the worker | None | None | None | The nomination is not withdrawn by it; the charge is refunded only for the reasons in reg 2.12F(3B) |
The “$3,727 each” entry is a reading. The Tribunal’s fees page lets it order a single fee where one applicant makes more than one application that can be dealt with together, and says that for these migration reviews that decision is final; the employer and the worker are different applicants, so each review reads as carrying its own fee.
A 186 refused on character grounds under section 501 of the Act follows a separate Tribunal pathway: the Tribunal’s immigration and citizenship page gives 9 days to apply if you were in Australia when refused, and its fees page applies the standard fee of $1,195 to character refusals, as at 24 September 2026.
Why are 186 nominations refused?
A 186 nomination is refused when an approval criterion in regulation 5.19 is not met, and the criteria fall under five points. No official figures show which ground is used most often, so the list follows the regulation, not frequency.
- (TRT and Direct Entry) The position is not genuine, not full time or not for at least 2 years. Regulation 5.19(5) and (9) require a genuine need for the worker in a position under the nominator’s direct control, full-time employment for at least 2 years, and terms that do not expressly exclude extending it; the Department adds that the contract “must not limit the position to 2 years”. The four tests and the evidence are covered under why genuine-position nominations are refused.
- (TRT and Direct Entry) The salary is too low or the market rate is not shown. Pay must be at least the annual market salary rate and the Core Skills Income Threshold, which is $79,423 for nominations lodged from 1 July 2026 to 30 June 2027 (reg 5.19(5)(o), (9)(h)); the employer need not show the market rate where earnings are at least $250,000. The Department warns that unlabelled salary surveys or vague explanations of the market rate may lead to refusal.
- (TRT and Direct Entry) The business is not actively and lawfully operating, or cannot employ the worker for 2 years at the market rate (reg 5.19(5), (9)).
- (All streams) Adverse information, a poor employment-law record, a licence the worker cannot get, or an unpaid levy debt. Regulation 5.19(4)(b)–(da) covers adverse information about the nominator or an associated person, a satisfactory record of compliance with workplace laws, any mandatory licence, registration or membership the worker must hold or be able to get, and any unpaid Skilling Australians Fund debt.
- Stream rules. In the TRT stream, the nominator is not the sponsor that last nominated the worker for a 482 or 457, or the occupation differs from the one the worker’s most recent 482 or 457 was granted for (reg 5.19(5)(b), (h)). In the Direct Entry stream, the occupation is not on the Core Skills Occupation List in section 7 of LIN 24/093, or a caveat in section 8 excludes the position. In the Labour Agreement stream, the occupation is not in the agreement, or the agreement’s yearly ceiling of approved nominations is used up (reg 5.19(14)). A Labour Agreement nomination is judged against its agreement’s terms, not against the TRT and Direct Entry salary and 2-year criteria in items 1 to 3.
For any of these grounds, the employer has two options: Tribunal review within 28 days, or a new nomination that fixes the gap, with a new fee of $540 (nil for TRT and Labour Agreement positions in regional Australia, reg 5.37) and a new levy of $3,000 or $5,000, as at 24 September 2026.
Why are 186 visa applications refused?
A 186 visa application is refused when the worker fails a criterion at lodgement or at decision, and the criteria fall under five points.
- No approved nomination, or the position is no longer available (cl 186.223(2)–(4), 186.233(3)–(5), 186.242(3)–(5)).
- A stream criterion not met at lodgement. For TRT and Direct Entry: under 45 unless in an exempt class (cl 186.221, 186.231), and competent English from a test taken in the 3 years before applying, or a passport from Canada, New Zealand, the Republic of Ireland, the United Kingdom or the United States (cl 186.222, 186.232; reg 1.15C). For Direct Entry: a positive skills assessment held at lodgement (cl 186.234(2)(a)) and 3 years of full-time experience (cl 186.234(2)(b)). For TRT: 2 years of full-time sponsored employment in the 3 years before applying (cl 186.226, 186.227). A TRT or Direct Entry application lodged more than 6 months after the nomination was approved also fails (cl 186.223(5), 186.233(6)). Labour Agreement: the age, English, skills and experience rules are those in the agreement (cl 186.241, 186.243), and the law sets no 6-month window.
- Health. Public interest criterion 4005 applies to Direct Entry and Labour Agreement applicants and has no waiver; public interest criterion 4007 applies to TRT applicants and allows one (cl 186.224, 186.235, 186.244).
- Character, security and Commonwealth debts. Public interest criteria 4001 to 4004 (cl 186.213).
- Bogus documents or false information. Public interest criterion 4020, which also bars a grant for 3 years after such a refusal, or 10 years where the failure concerns identity (Schedule 4 cl 4020(2), (2B), (4)).
What happens to the visa if the nomination is refused or withdrawn?
If the 186 nomination is refused or withdrawn, the visa cannot be granted, because every stream needs an approved, unwithdrawn nomination for a position that is still available. That rule sits in clauses 186.223(2)–(4), 186.233(3)–(5) and 186.242(3)–(5) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations, one for each stream.
Can a new nomination be linked to your application?
No, the Department says it cannot link a new nomination to an existing 186 visa application, so the worker may withdraw and lodge a new one. The first instalment of the visa application charge can then be refunded only for the reasons in regulation 2.12F(3B), which include:
- a nomination that named the wrong occupation, or was withdrawn before decision because it was made in the wrong stream;
- a nomination withdrawn in the circumstances in regulation 5.37A(3)–(5);
- sanctions taken against the nominator under section 140K of the Act;
- the nominator’s business ceasing to operate;
- in the TRT stream, the worker losing the 482 or 457 job before the nomination was decided.
Withdrawing a 186 application or nomination
A 186 withdrawal is made by whoever lodged the application: the worker withdraws the visa application, the employer withdraws the nomination. There are three steps, and the Department’s page on withdrawing a visa application governs the first and third.
Review or reapply?
After a 186 refusal you can ask the Administrative Review Tribunal to review it within 28 days or lodge a new application, and the letter and your visa status decide which is open. The Tribunal replaced the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 14 October 2024, so a website that still names the old tribunal, or gives a shorter deadline, is out of date.
The table below compares the options, as at 24 September 2026.
| Option | Who acts | When | Government cost | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tribunal review | Employer (nomination) or worker in Australia (visa) | Within 28 days of notification | $3,727; 50% hardship reduction; 50% refunded if the refusal is set aside, varied or remitted | No extension (s 347(5)) |
| New 186 lodged in Australia | Worker, with a nomination from the employer | While holding a substantive visa or a Bridging visa A, B or C, and not barred by s 48 | Visa $6,140 for the main applicant from 1 July 2026; a new nomination $540 (nil for TRT and Labour Agreement positions in regional Australia), plus the levy of $3,000 or $5,000 | The s 48 bar, which applies “whether or not the application has been finally determined” (s 48(1)(b)(i)); the public interest criterion 4020 bar |
| New 186 lodged outside Australia | Worker | After leaving Australia | As above | Section 48 applies only to a non-citizen in the migration zone (s 48(1)) |
| Ask the Minister to intervene | Worker | Only after the Tribunal decides | Not stated in the sources read | The Minister acts personally and has no duty to consider a request (s 351(3), (7)) |
Section 48 is the trap in the second row. A person in Australia without a substantive visa who has been refused a visa since last entering can apply only for the classes listed in regulation 2.12, and the 186 (Class EN) is not one of them. Who may apply, the fee rules and what the Tribunal can decide are set out under 186 visa review.
Does the Department publish 186 refusal numbers?
The Department does not publish refusal numbers for the 186 alone (as at 24 September 2026): its Migration Program reporting gives grant and refusal rates for the Employer Sponsored category only, which is not a 186-only figure.
So a 186 can be refused, at the nomination stage or at the visa stage, but no published rate says how often. The Department’s planning levels page sets the Employer Sponsored category at 58,040 places in 2026–27, up from 44,000 in 2025–26; that is a ceiling on places, not a success rate. What each published series does and does not say is set out under is a 186 visa success rate published.
Next steps after a 186 refusal
After a 186 refusal, read the letter for the notification date, the criterion and the review rights (Act s 66(2); reg 5.19(15)), then take one of two steps before day 28.
- Choose review or a new application. A new application repeats both halves of the process, and the steps are set out under how to apply for a 186 visa.
- Decide who acts on the letter. A refusal is where the deadline and the s 48 bar leave least room for error; what a migration lawyer does for a 186 is set out on the migration lawyer page.
What changed on this page
| Date | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 24 September 2026 | Page published: refusal decision table with the 28-day review deadline (Migration Act s 347(3)) and the $3,727 Tribunal fee for fees paid from 1 July 2026. | Administrative Review Tribunal, Fees |
In this section
28 days, and no extension
After a 186 refusal the Tribunal deadline cannot be extended, the employer and the worker hold different review rights, and a wrong step can bar a new application in Australia. An Australian migration lawyer can read the letter and set out both parties' options before the deadline, which makes a grant on review or on a new application more likely.
Ask about your 186