Visa 186 Australia

Employer side

Genuine Position for a 186 Nomination: What the Department Tests and the Evidence

A genuine position for a 186 nomination is one the employer genuinely needs filled, under its direct control and full time for at least 2 years, and for TRT and Direct Entry the Department tests it on evidence such as the organisation chart, the position description and the business's financial records.

Checked against Home Affairs and the Migration Regulations · updated

Want an immigration lawyer to check your 186 before it is lodged? Ask about your 186

A workshop wall with a single empty tool outline on a pegboard among other hanging tools, a work apron on a hook.
Genuine-need test
TRT reg 5.19(5)(k); Direct Entry reg 5.19(9)(d)the need is for the named worker, in the position, under the employer's direct control · as at 24 September 2026
Position length
Full time for at least 2 years, and the contract must not limit it to 2 yearsreg 5.19(5)(l)–(m), (9)(e)–(f); Department TRT and Direct Entry pages, updated 3 August 2026
Evidence the Department lists first
A detailed organisational structure chart and a detailed position descriptionTRT and Direct Entry pages (Sponsor view)
TRT occupations not tested on the need and full-time paragraphs
36chief executive or managing director, corporate general manager, 34 medical practitioner occupations · reg 5.19(7); LIN 19/212 s 6
Labour Agreement stream
No genuine-need paragraphthe agreement's own requirements must be met · reg 5.19(14)(c)

The tests sit in regulation 5.19(5)(j)–(n) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) for TRT and 5.19(9)(b)–(g) for Direct Entry, a Labour Agreement nomination is tested on its agreement instead, and a nomination the Minister is not satisfied meets them must be refused (regulation 5.19(3)(b)). The genuine position sits beside the salary rules and the employer’s obligations as a condition of approval, and this page sets out each test with its paragraph and its evidence.

Test TRT paragraph Direct Entry paragraph Documents that prove it
Need identified and genuine, under the employer’s direct control (5)(j)–(k) (9)(c)–(d) Detailed organisational structure chart; detailed position description with tasks and duties; TRT: a statement of how the position continues to fit into the business; Direct Entry: the occupation’s name and ANZSCO code, plus, where applicable, attrition, temporary-resident occupant, new business, overtime or diversification evidence
Full time for at least 2 years, extension not excluded (5)(l)–(m) (9)(e)–(f) The employment contract: full time, ongoing, available for at least 2 years, not limited to 2 years
Capacity to employ for 2 years and pay the market rate (5)(n) (9)(g) Audited balance sheet and profit and loss statement, or business tax returns and assessment notices, for the last financial year; BAS for later quarters; under 12 months old: BAS and bank statements
Business actively and lawfully operating (5)(h)(ii) (9)(a) Current lease; trust deed pages if a trust
Direct Entry only: position not for hire to unrelated businesses None (9)(b) No separate document listed; the organisation chart and position description show where the position sits

Sources: regulation 5.19 and the Department’s TRT and Direct Entry pages, read 24 September 2026. TRT nominations for the 36 occupations in LIN 19/212 are not tested on (5)(j)–(l) (regulation 5.19(7)). Labour Agreement nominations are tested under regulation 5.19(14).

What is a genuine position for a 186 nomination?

A genuine position for a 186 nomination is a position the employer genuinely needs the named worker to fill, under its own direct control and full time for at least 2 years, and in the TRT and Direct Entry streams the Minister must be satisfied of that need before approving the nomination (Migration Regulations 1994, regulation 5.19(5)(k) and (9)(d)).

The Department’s Direct Entry page says “Businesses seeking to nominate overseas workers for a permanent employer sponsored visa are required to demonstrate that there is a genuine need to employ a person in the position”. The TRT page asks the business to demonstrate “a continuing genuine need”. “Genuine position” is the everyday name; the Regulations speak of a genuine need for the identified person to be employed in the position.

A 186 is possible without a 482: Direct Entry needs no earlier 482, which is why its list of genuine-need evidence is longer (see the Direct Entry section below).

What does the Department test?

The Department tests four things about a 186 position in the TRT and Direct Entry streams: a genuine need for the worker under the employer’s direct control, full-time employment for at least 2 years, terms that do not expressly rule out extending it, and a business able to employ the worker and pay at least the market rate for those 2 years.

  1. Genuine need under the employer’s direct control, identified in the application (regulation 5.19(5)(j)–(k); (9)(c)–(d)).
  2. Full time for at least 2 years (regulation 5.19(5)(l); (9)(e)). The 2 years binds the position the employer offers, not the granted visa, as the page on the 186 visa 2-year commitment explains.
  3. No express exclusion of extension (regulation 5.19(5)(m); (9)(f)). The Department adds that the contract “must not limit the position to 2 years”.
  4. Capacity to employ the worker for at least 2 years and pay at least the annual market salary rate each year (regulation 5.19(5)(n); (9)(g)).

For TRT, the employer must also have given the information the Minister requires for tests 1 to 4 (regulation 5.19(5)(q)).

Regulation 5.19(7) switches off paragraphs (5)(j), (k) and (l) for TRT nominations in the 36 occupations in LIN 19/212: chief executive or managing director, corporate general manager, and 34 medical practitioner occupations from general practitioner to medical practitioners not elsewhere classified. Tests 3 and 4 still apply to them, and Direct Entry has no equivalent exception.

Advertising the role is not one of the tests.

What evidence shows the position is genuine?

Six kinds of evidence show the position is genuine, and the Department lists them on its TRT and Direct Entry pages: an organisation chart, a position description, the employment contract, the business’s financial records, proof the business is operating, and evidence of why the position is needed.

  1. “A detailed organisational structure chart” (both streams).
  2. “A detailed position description including specified tasks and duties of the position” (both streams); the Direct Entry list adds “the name of the occupation and its ANZSCO code”.
  3. The employment contract, showing the base salary, the total remuneration and terms, and that the position is “full-time, ongoing and available for at least 2 years” (both streams).
  4. Financial records: an audited balance sheet and profit and loss statement for the most recent financial year with comparative figures, or business tax returns and assessment notices, plus a BAS for each complete quarter since if that period ended more than three months before lodging. A business under 12 months old gives BAS and business bank statements from the start of operations.
  5. Proof of operation: the current lease, and trust deed pages naming the parties if the business is a trust.
  6. The need itself. TRT: “a statement outlining how the position continues to fit into the business activities”. Direct Entry, where applicable: evidence that the position became vacant through attrition, is occupied by a temporary resident, is needed for an increase in business activity (for example new contracts won), is shown by overtime in the occupation, or, for a diversifying business, market research, business plans, budgets and evidence of funding.

The Department’s lists name documents. They do not name a “genuine position report” or require one.

Direct Entry: genuine need and positions for hire

In Direct Entry, a business that hires out labour to other unrelated businesses can nominate only a position within its own business activities, not one for hire to unrelated businesses (Migration Regulations 1994, regulation 5.19(9)(b)).

The Department words it as: “if it undertakes activities related to hiring labour to other unrelated businesses, the position must be within your business activities and not for hire to other unrelated businesses”. In the Regulations this is a Direct Entry paragraph. The Department’s TRT page lists the same condition among its business requirements, although regulation 5.19(5) has no matching paragraph; this page reports both without drawing a legal conclusion.

Because a Direct Entry worker has no 482 history with the business, the “where applicable” evidence carries the need: attrition, a temporary-resident occupant, new business, overtime or diversification. A diversifying business shows market research, business plans with timelines, financial budgets and evidence that funding is available.

Why genuine-position nominations are refused

Genuine-position nominations are refused when the Minister is not satisfied of one of three things: that the business genuinely needs the worker in the position, that the position is full time for at least 2 years with no bar on extension, or that the business can employ and pay the worker at the market rate for 2 years (regulation 5.19(3)(b)).

  1. The need is not shown. Evidence is missing, or the organisation chart and position description do not show where the position fits. The Department can decide “without making a further request”.
  2. The terms fail. A part-time role, or a contract that limits the position to 2 years.
  3. Capacity fails. Financial records that do not show the business can employ and pay at least the market rate for 2 years (regulation 5.19(5)(n), (9)(g)). For the salary evidence, the Department warns that “unlabelled salary surveys or vague details on how you determined the AMSR” may lead to refusal.

The Department publishes no refusal rate for 186 nominations. The refusal letter states the reasons and whether review rights exist (regulation 5.19(15)), and only the nominator can apply to the Administrative Review Tribunal, within 28 days of being notified. The other grounds, and why are 186 nominations refused more generally, are covered on the refusal page.

Does the Labour Agreement stream test a genuine position?

The Labour Agreement stream does not test a genuine position under regulation 5.19: its nomination criteria are that the employer is a party to a labour agreement in effect that names the occupation, meets any requirement the agreement specifies, and has not reached its yearly ceiling of approved nominations (regulation 5.19(14)(a)–(d)).

If the agreement itself contains a genuine-need term, that term must be met (regulation 5.19(14)(c)). The general criteria in regulation 5.19(4), covering adverse information, the employment-law record, licences and any SAF debt, apply to every stream.

What the worker should know about the genuine position

The worker should know that the genuine position is the employer’s test, but a nomination refused on it stops the worker’s 186, because the visa cannot be granted unless the nomination is approved (Schedule 2 clauses 186.223 and 186.233).

For TRT, the Department must hold no information that the worker is not genuinely performing the tasks of the occupation as ANZSCO describes them (regulation 5.19(5)(d)). The worker should check that the contract says full time and ongoing, with no 2-year end date. The worker cannot apply for review of a refused nomination; only the employer can. A worker without a 482 whose employer nominates in Direct Entry also has to meet what are the Direct Entry requirements on the worker’s side.

What changed on this page

DateChangeSource
24 September 2026Page published: the genuine-need, full-time, extension and capacity tests read from reg 5.19(5) and (9) (Compilation 288), the reg 5.19(7) exception (LIN 19/212), and the evidence the Department lists on the TRT and Direct Entry pages (updated 3 August 2026).Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), reg 5.19

A genuine need has to be shown, not asserted

A nomination the Department does not accept as genuine is refused, the fee and levy are generally not refunded, and the worker's visa cannot be granted on it. An Australian migration lawyer can check the organisation chart, the position description, the contract and the financial records against regulation 5.19 before lodgement, which makes approval more likely.

Ask about your 186